[ Date Prev ][ Date Next ][ Thread Prev ][ Thread Next ][ Date Index ][ Thread Index ]

MITRE/CVE and FIRST/CVSSv3 mismatch in idetifying vulnerabilities



So MITRE/CVE allows for intersection vulns which involve more than a single vulnerable component. FIRST/CVSSv3 doesn't appear to:

https://www.first.org/cvss/specification-document

The Exploitability metrics reflect the ease and technical means by which the vulnerability can be exploited. That is, they represent characteristics of the  thing that is vulnerable , which we refer to formally as the vulnerable component . On the other hand, the Impact metrics reflect the direct consequence of a successful exploit, and represent the consequence to the  thing that suffers the impact , which we refer to formally as the  impacted component .

While the vulnerable component is typically a software application, module, driver, etc. (or possibly even a hardware device), the impacted component could be a software application, a hardware device or a network resource. This potential for measuring the impact of a vulnerability other than the vulnerable component, is a key feature of CVSS v3.0. This property is captured, and further discussed by the Scope metric below.

I was hoping to get some clarification from FIRST on this (CC'ed), does "vulnerable component" mean a single thing only, or can it mean multiple components which intersect to create a vuln?

Also we should probably have some more cross pollination to determine/define these basic terms and make sure we're all on the same page (like what is hardware, e.g. FPGA's fit in where in this pile?). 


--

--
Kurt Seifried -- Red Hat -- Product Security -- Cloud
PGP A90B F995 7350 148F 66BF 7554 160D 4553 5E26 7993
Red Hat Product Security contact:  secalert@redhat.com

Page Last Updated or Reviewed: September 06, 2016